Comunidad de Propietarios · Marbella, Málaga
Transparent governance · Public record · Open archive
Archive / Records / Working Group Terms of Reference — 2022
← Back to records
NEWSLETTER Newsletter · 2022-12-31

Working Group Terms of Reference — 2022

Download PDF ES
Reference 2022-working-group-terms-of-reference
Document Type Newsletter newsletter
Date 2022-12-31 (30 December 2022)
Issued by Adenjo Gestión SL
Affects All buildings (5 of 5)
Available in ENESSVARFR
Storage ?Cryptographic hash for verifying that this file matches the original on record. r2://2022/Working_Group_Terms_of_Reference.pdf
This is a translation. The Spanish version is the legally authoritative document. View original

Owner-prepared summary. Original document is the authoritative source.

At a glance

  • The document dated 31 December 2022 establishes a volunteer Working Group to advise the President and Community Administrator on large‑scale structural repair and refurbishment projects affecting multiple residential buildings.
  • The Working Group operates in an advisory capacity; final decisions remain with the President, Administrator and Owners’ Assembly under the Ley de Propiedad Horizontal.
  • It is supported by an Advisory Group with technical and finance‑legal sub‑teams, and comprises two sub‑groups: a Project Finance Working Group and a Construction Evaluation Working Group, each with a designated lead and members.
  • Responsibilities include analysing financing options, evaluating construction bids, preparing reports, and coordinating information flow through a Working Group Communications Coordinator who manages a central digital document repository and bi‑weekly status meetings.
  • Confidentiality provisions require that commercially sensitive information be shared only within the Working Groups, Advisory Group, President and Administrator.

Page 1

WORKING GROUP TERMS OF REFERENCE Major Structural Repair & Refurbishment Programme This mandate establishes a Working Group of volunteer owners to assist the President and the Community Administration in analysing options and preparing recommendations relating to anticipated large-scale structural and infrastructure repair works affecting multiple residential buildings within the community, some of which are now deemed urgent. The Working Group operates in an advisory capacity and has no executive authority. Formal decisions remain the responsibility of the President, the Community Administrator and ultimately the Owners’ Assembly in accordance with the Ley de Propiedad Horizontal. The purpose of the Working Group is to ensure the community benefits from structured owner participation in analysing financing options, evaluating construction proposals and supporting the preparation of informed recommendations. Governance Structure The President retains overall leadership and final decision-making. He may attend Working Group meetings, request updates, or modify the scope of work if necessary in order to ensure alignment with the interests of the Community. For example: Owner risk & impact considerations; & the AFO process to regularise 3 buildings. All recommendations developed by the Working Group will ultimately be reported to the President. Advisory Group The Advisory Group comprising of those already engaged in the Project provides professional expertise, institutional knowledge and technical expertise to guide the work of the Working Groups. The Advisory Group will review findings, clarify technical matters, and assist in interpreting financial or construction documentation. The Advisory Group is divided into two functional areas: Technical Advisory • Victor Porras – Site Manager • Francisco Manuel López Chacón – Senior Technical Architect Finance and Legal Advisory • Adenjo – Community Administrator • Gerry Burke – Community Vice President (Finance)

Page 2

Working Groups 1) Project Finance Working Group Responsible for analysing financing options and evaluating possible funding structures for the project. Lead • Rania Moumni – Mezquita Members •Angelique Flag - Giralda • Omar El Figuigui – Triana • Per Nyberg Bergfors – Mezquita Responsibilities include: • evaluating potential bank financing options • reviewing loan structures and repayment scenarios • evaluating loan securitisation requirements • assessing potential financial & securitisation impact on owners • preparing comparative financing scenarios • evaluate repayment scenarios for owners opting out of a bank loan • assess the impact of long term debtors on the funding dynamics Key Deliverables A report outlining available financing options and financial scenarios 2) Construction Evaluation Working Group Responsible for reviewing technical documentation and assisting with the evaluation of construction bids. Lead • Ghada Al Naimi – Giralda Members • Anders Tibor Rupp – Alhambra • Maan Niman Alyan – Mezquita

Page 3

• Jan Schilder – Doñana Responsibilities include: • reviewing technical project documentation • assisting with the identification of qualified contractors including up to two additional to those already presented at the EGM • supporting the ‘request for proposals’ process • reviewing contractor build proposals • identifying & reconciling major differences in scope, price or schedule • identify key project risks and considerations based on the information reviewed Key Deliverables • A comparative evaluation of contractor bids and technical proposals • A summary of key project risks and considerations Working Group Communications Coordinator • Ilan Sluis – Doñana The role of the Coordinator is to facilitate the smooth flow of information between the two Working Groups, the Advisory Group and the President. The Coordinator’s responsibilities include: • helping to coordinate Zoom & in-person meetings between the parties • supporting coordination of information requests • establishing a document repository for shared documentation • helping ensure transparency of information flow Requests for Information Requests for major data, clarification or technical information should normally originate from the relevant Working Group Lead. Where appropriate, these requests may be coordinated with the assistance of the Working Group Coordinator. Requests may be directed to: • members of the Advisory Group

Page 4

• architects or technical consultants • banks or financial institutions • construction companies participating in the tender process To ensure transparency and good coordination, the President and Advisory Group should be informed not less than 48 hours in advance before the commencement of any formal communication or engagement with external parties. Once communication is established the Group Lead should ensure that discussions are minuted. Document Management A central digital document repository to be established by the Coordinator to store project documentation in one place. Typical folders may include: • technical project documentation • contractor tender documentation • contractor proposals • financial proposals from banks • Working Group reports • meeting notes and summaries Access will be structured to allow Working Group members appropriate access while maintaining confidentiality of any sensitive material. All project-related documentation should be stored in this central repository to ensure transparency and avoid fragmentation of information. Meetings and Status Updates To recognise that each sub-group might wish to know what is happening in the other group, a bi-weekly Zoom meeting will be organised by the Coordinator. Each Working Group may organise internal meetings as required. Brief status updates may be prepared weekly & shared with the President & Advisory Group outlining: • work completed • key findings or issues • requests for additional information

Page 5

• next planned steps Confidentiality Certain information involved in the project may be commercially sensitive, including: • contractor pricing • financial proposals from banks • technical reports • legal or engineering advice Such information should be treated as confidential and shared only within the Working Groups, Advisory Group, President and Administrator unless otherwise authorised. Working Approach Members are expected to collaborate constructively, share relevant information and maintain clear communication through the agreed structure. The objective of the initiative is to assist the Community in reaching well-informed decisions regarding the future repair and maintenance of the buildings. Issued on behalf of the Community, John Riley President SdA March 2026.

View PDF inlineWorking_Group_Terms_of_Reference.pdf
Permalink copied